TUMBLR

A scrapbook of stuff I'm reading / looking at / listening to / thinking about...



“Maps are arguments.” There’s a great Denis Wood...

Feb 09, 2012
Permalink
“Maps are arguments.” There’s a great Denis Wood interview by Blake Butler worth seeking out in last month’s Believer where they talk about cartography, maps, and Wood’s book, Everything Sings. If you compare Google Earth and Google Maps, for example, Google Earth in its naked, unlayered form is a bunch of pictures. They’re not maps. You have no idea what you’re looking at, and to the extent that you do have some idea, it’s something you’re bringing to the image. Pictures and words don’t have anything to do with each other. If you look at Google Maps, on the other hand, or an annotated version of Google Earth, which turns it into a map—there’s a label that says this is a desert, this is a mountain, this is a river, this is Kazakhstan, this is Mongolia—well, that’s what makes a map something other than a picture… Filed under: maps Update: here’s a PDF of the interview on Wood’s site.

“Maps are arguments.” There’s a great Denis Wood interview by Blake Butler worth seeking out in last month’s Believer where they talk about cartography, maps, and Wood’s book, Everything Sings.

If you compare Google Earth and Google Maps, for example, Google Earth in its naked, unlayered form is a bunch of pictures. They’re not maps. You have no idea what you’re looking at, and to the extent that you do have some idea, it’s something you’re bringing to the image. Pictures and words don’t have anything to do with each other. If you look at Google Maps, on the other hand, or an annotated version of Google Earth, which turns it into a map—there’s a label that says this is a desert, this is a mountain, this is a river, this is Kazakhstan, this is Mongolia—well, that’s what makes a map something other than a picture…

Filed under: maps

Update: here’s a PDF of the interview on Wood’s site.

131 notes | ∞ | Permalink
« Older Post
Newer Post »

131 notes

  1. dianebluegreen reblogged this from curiositycounts
  2. everydaylifecourse reblogged this from fuckyeahcartography
  3. iwokeupthirstythedayidied reblogged this from fuckyeahcartography
  4. thesoundofwateronly reblogged this from someyes
  5. someyes reblogged this from fuckyeahcartography
  6. fuckyeahcartography reblogged this from austinkleon
  7. fivegoldfish reblogged this from curiositycounts
  8. katykanban reblogged this from curiositycounts
  9. arrangedcolor reblogged this from fantagraphics
  10. zippz reblogged this from curiositycounts
  11. whatitalkaboutwhenitalkabout reblogged this from slavin and added:
    “Maps are arguments.” Excerpt from a fantastic interview with counterculture cartographer Denis Wood, whose Everything...
  12. trustyoureditor reblogged this from fantagraphics
  13. jeshilu reblogged this from fantagraphics
  14. melaniegarza reblogged this from believermag
  15. andreagin reblogged this from believermag and added:
    Such an interesting idea…
  16. dippingandrising reblogged this from curiositycounts and added:
    It’s worth noting that the whole “maps...arguments” thing was radical when Wood started...
  17. matthew-matthias reblogged this from curiositycounts
  18. enriquelozano reblogged this from fantagraphics
  19. maschup reblogged this from curiositycounts