A scrapbook of stuff I'm reading / looking at / listening to / thinking about...
Nov 05, 2009
» Dash Shaw, "Teach House Styles"
What Shaw is really getting at here is using constraints in the classroom. Instead of cartooning whatever you feel like, draw an Archie strip. It would hold equal weight in a creative writing class. Instead of writing whatever you want, write a horror story.
Personal style and originality would be put on hold. In our current cult of originality, the pressure is to have a personal style as soon as possible, and the classroom environments often have this mentality as well. Everyone is freaking out: “What’s my style? What’s my thing?” It’s too much too fast. This race for originality has, over the years, spread from that future-goal timeline to just after college to (now) inside college itself. A safety zone no longer exists. For the most part, hardly anyone is hiring newbies fresh out of college to draw in a house style and then expect them to grow out of it. If these classes are explicitly devoted to learning a specific form, the anxiety for uniqueness would disappear and everyone would breathe out and look at their comics. The college would be the safety zone and after they graduate they’d start doing their own thing.
Yes, yes, yes. And even more importantly, don’t teach tools.
There would be no courses devoted to “tools,” no penciling or inking classes. People can learn that elsewhere, like in their foundation year drawing classes. When that separation of responsibilities is brought into the cartooning class it’s usually based on an American production model that leads to people struggling with a tool for a whole year when they’re naturally suited to something else.
Subscribe to my newsletter and get new art, writing, and interesting links delivered to your inbox every week.