A scrapbook of stuff I'm reading / looking at / listening to / thinking about...
Posts tagged "songwriting"
One of my favorite songs is Otis Redding’s cut of “Try A Little Tenderness.” Here he is doing it live in 1967.
The song has an interesting history. It’s first incarnation was written in the Tin Pan Alley heyday, in 1933, by the songwriting duo Jimmy Campbell and Reg Connelly with composer Harry M. Woods. It was first done by Ray Noble and his orchestra:
Columbia records was attempting to market Franklin as a pop singer and consequently recorded her singing any number of Tin Pan Alley standards replete with pop string arrangements. These records were a far cry from her later Atlantic rhythm and blues hits in terms of instrumentation, arrangement, and performance style. That said, Franklin cannot and does not completely shed her gospel background and consequently, at least to a small degree, transforms the song when compared to the Crosby and Sinatra recordings.
When Sam Cooke heard it, he chose to sing it at the Copa, “attempting to appeal to an older white, middle- and upper-class audience”:
And now we’re getting somewhere. Otis Redding’s manager, Phil Walden, had been trying to talk him into doing the song for a while. Walden recalls:
I remember he called me late at night and he said, “You know that song you’ve been on my ass about recording, ‘Try A Little Tenderness’? I said, ‘Yeah.’ He said, ‘I cut that motherfucker. It’s a brand-new song.
And so it was. But get this lineup: the Stax label’s house band was Booker T and the MGs, and Isaac Hayes was producing and arranging (and playing the organ) with the Mar-Key horns.
More from Soulsville, USA:
Isaac Hayes was responsible for much [of the arrangement], including the three-part contrapuntal horn line in the intro (inspired by the strings on Sam Cooke’s “A Change Is Gonna Come”) and the cymbal break in the climax (which Hayes later reused on “Theme from Shaft”). The idea of having Al Jackson lay out during the first verse and then come in on the second verse of the song simply by tapping quarter-beats on the rim of the snare came about accidentally when the drummer idly tapped along while Redding was running down the tune.
There’s also a ton of ad-libbing by Redding, some of which incorporates lyrics from the Duke Ellington song, “Just Squeeze Me (But Don’t Tease Me)”:
The song took only three takes. Here’s the final result:
And of course, about 50 years later, Kanye West and Jay-Z sampled the song for their track “Otis,” off Watch The Throne:
I tweeted this a few days ago and got some excellent responses, so I wanted to share them here:
Paul Zollo’s Songwriters on Songwriting seems to be the classic text on the subject
Bill Flanagan’s Written in My Soul: Conversations with Rock’s Great Songwriters (Flanagan went on to create VH1’s Storytellers)
The NYTimes’ “Measure for Measure” blog, where “Songwriters pull back the curtain on their creative process”
The Guardian’s “How We Made” series where “two collaborators on a seminal art work talk us through their original creative process.” Several of the columns are about songs: the Four Tops’ “Reach Out,” Ben E. King and Mike Stoller on “Stand By Me,” The Kinks on “You Really Got Me,” etc.
The podcast Song Exploder, though not necessarily about songwriting, is great for recording nerds
What am I missing?
Every week, Bob Schneider emails an invite-only group of musicians (several of them Grammy winners) with a challenge to write a song containing a certain phrase. If, by the end of the week, they don’t meet the challenge, they’re off the list.
The primary factor stopping people from finishing songs is the critical voice in your head that says it isn’t good enough. Then there’s the part of your brain that thinks every idea you have is wonderful. Those two are in constant battle when you’re writing. With [the songwriting game], you simply have to turn it in. If it’s bad or mediocre or half a song or maybe just a good idea not realized in a workable way, it doesn’t matter. Even the worst songwriter in the world, forced to write a song every week, is going to write some good songs from time to time. Law of averages.
Schneider has written a song a week for 12 years. More on the challenge here.